The antics of the dealer lobby know no bounds. It is now being alleged by the group's lobbyist that numismatists in favor of the protection of ancient coins have ghost-written each others comments to CPAC. As absurd as the notion is, I suppose it is not unexpected from those quarters. Conspiracy theories are endemic among the dealer lobby's leadership, which is quite indicative of the desperation of their position.
And yes, there is something seemingly duplicitous in one lobby leader's acknowledgment of ancient Egypt's closed currency system before the lobby's founding, and then later pretending it did not exist when commenting on the potential MOU with Egypt. These intellectual changes of heart also speak to the desperation of their argument that coins do not merit or warrant protection.
Update, 5/27. Digging the hole deeper, the paid lobbyist, Peter Tompa, assumes I sent comments to CPAC on the potential MOU with Egypt and now demands that I make these presumed comments public. I am not sure who he thinks he is to make such demands. Nonetheless, whether or not I elected to exercise my right to make a comment is my decision alone and the CPAC allows comments to be submitted any number of ways.
He attempts to qualify his unusual interest in the matter: "CPO [Peter Tompa] does not question Elkins' (or anyone else's) rights to express their
views to CPAC, just his unwillingness to let others assess for
themselves their accuracy." I must say past actions do not bear this out. 1. The dealer lobby's leadership and its lobbyist do not rely on logic and facts to construct arguments, as the recent episode regarding circulation patterns in Egypt illustrates. 2. I recall multiple instances in which the dealer lobby (and yes, the lobbyist in question) have attempted to intimidate and perhaps even to undermine the employment of those who have voiced support for MOUs and advocated the protection of coins. And finally, it is not up to agenda-driven lobbyists to "assess for themselves the accuracy" of comments submitted to CPAC - that is up to the respective members of CPAC, appointed by the President.